U-Games

2 members have put Kane & Lynch: Dead Men on their wishlist, while another 2 even own the game.
zoefkeHerrdidifrederik850
You can manage your own collection by registering or logging in.

Game Details

Kane & Lynch: Dead Men

Kane & Lynch: Dead Men

Available on :
Pc
Xbox 360
Playstation 3
 
Developed by :
Published by :
Genre :
Third Person Action Game

Description

Kane & Lynch: Dead Men follows the violent and chaotic journey of two men - a flawed mercenary and a medicated psychopath – and their brutal attitude towards right and wrong. This volatile partnership combined with innovative technologies allow ...

RSS Feeds

Feeds are per category

News

Gamespot = Corrupt?

Posted on Friday, 30 November 2007 by Speed, source: Joystiq
Ok, the title may be a bit over the top, but one does have to wonder what's going on over there.

Joystiq is reporting that Gamespot and its parent CNet have fired a reviewer after the guy gave Kane & Lynch: Dead Men a score of 6/10 while Eidos was advertising quite heavily on Gamespot for that same game.

Apparently Eidos didn't like that and requested CNET to fire the reviewer, something that indeed happen.

word around game journalism's virtual water cooler is that Gamespot Editorial Director Jeff Gerstmann has been fired because publisher Eidos was unhappy about his negative review of Kane & Lynch: Dead Men

Gamespot has also removed Jeff Gerstmann's video review of the game from their site which would suggest there's some truth to the story.

Gerstmann himself apparently isn't allowed to comment on the reasons for his departure:

Jeff has confirmed his firing to us via e-mail, but says he's "not really able to comment on the specifics of my termination." He added that he's "looking forward to getting back out there and figuring out what's next." We're still digging

Gamespot did comment on the matter with word that they "take editorial integrity extremely seriously" but no word on whether anything about the matter is true or not.

Joystiq is following up on the story and regularly updating their post with new info as it comes in.
In other news:

11 Comment(s)

selder

selder

who cares? who the hell listens to those crap reviews anyway? Don't you have an own opinion?
who cares? who the hell listens to those crap reviews anyway? Don't you have an own opinion?
Quote
Posted on 22:29, November 30th 2007
Speed

Speed

In theory, reviews are used to help you make a decision on which game to buy and which to leave on store shelves. How can you make your own opinion if you've never played the game? Based on hype and rumours?
In theory, reviews are used to help you make a decision on which game to buy and which to leave on store shelves. How can you make your own opinion if you've never played the game? Based on hype and rumours?
Quote
Posted on 23:23, November 30th 2007
decypher

decypher

I don't anyone takes Gamespot seriously anyway... It's a well-known fact that it's just a shitty sellout.
I don't anyone takes Gamespot seriously anyway... It's a well-known fact that it's just a shitty sellout.
Quote
Posted on 23:34, November 30th 2007
derf26 (old)

derf26 (old)

I've never really liked Gamespot's reviews much tbh. They gave good games (imo) 7s and 8s, and gave relatively poor games with little innovation 8.5s and 9s. Wonder if that's corruption or incomptence?
I've never really liked Gamespot's reviews much tbh. They gave good games (imo) 7s and 8s, and gave relatively poor games with little innovation 8.5s and 9s. Wonder if that's corruption or incomptence?
Quote
Posted on 00:19, December 01st 2007
Anonymous

Anonymous

A concept of a review is very "fragile" since it's based on the opinion of ONE single dude and the chance of his likings being the same as "yours" are fairly slim at best...add to that that rumor has t a good portion of "reviews" are bought and paid for by companies with financial interests in positive reviews...

Don't take a review for more than it is and use it to find out about graphics, gameplay etc if it's described at all...I only use reviews when there's no demo available.
A concept of a review is very "fragile" since it's based on the opinion of ONE single dude and the chance of his likings being the same as "yours" are fairly slim at best...add to that that rumor has t a good portion of "reviews" are bought and paid for by companies with financial interests in positive reviews... Don't take a review for more than it is and use it to find out about graphics, gameplay etc if it's described at all...I only use reviews when there's no demo available.
Quote
Posted on 00:55, December 01st 2007
Zwan

Zwan

It sure puts the 9.5 they gave Halo 3 in a whole different perspective.
It sure puts the 9.5 they gave Halo 3 in a whole different perspective.
Quote
Posted on 01:26, December 01st 2007
NINJAFISH

NINJAFISH

Pulling the review is one thing, but actually firing the guy? It doesnt get any more obvious then that.

The only legitimate way this could have gone down however unlikely, is if his intent was just to bad mouth the game and give it low scores without the reasoning as to why he gave it a low score.

Although I know its common practice to have advertisements for video games on a video game review site, doesn't it seem a bit hypocritical?
Pulling the review is one thing, but actually firing the guy? It doesnt get any more obvious then that. The only legitimate way this could have gone down however unlikely, is if his intent was just to bad mouth the game and give it low scores without the reasoning as to why he gave it a low score. Although I know its common practice to have advertisements for video games on a video game review site, doesn't it seem a bit hypocritical?
Quote
Posted on 07:23, December 01st 2007
Anonymous

Anonymous

if you dont have inet halo3 is not worth the money but if you got i net its a cool game if u ask me :D
if you dont have inet halo3 is not worth the money but if you got i net its a cool game if u ask me :D
Quote
Posted on 07:54, December 01st 2007
Anonymous

Anonymous

ye gamespot suxballs,its run by large companys that try to decieve hardworkin peeps that pay overinflated prices for there games,kane and lynch is shite its like a badly made game from 10 yrs ago.....gamespot should b ashamed of themselves the greedy corrupt foks
ye gamespot suxballs,its run by large companys that try to decieve hardworkin peeps that pay overinflated prices for there games,kane and lynch is shite its like a badly made game from 10 yrs ago.....gamespot should b ashamed of themselves the greedy corrupt foks
Quote
Posted on 12:30, December 01st 2007
selder

selder

want to test the games before buying them? Download the warez, test it for yourself, and have the balls to buy a game you are actually playing!
want to test the games before buying them? Download the warez, test it for yourself, and have the balls to buy a game you are actually playing!
Quote
Posted on 16:14, December 01st 2007
ducksmuggler

ducksmuggler

geffs review is on you tube .

just goes to show that like most major publications and sites gamespots reviews are paid for by the games industry
geffs review is on you tube . just goes to show that like most major publications and sites gamespots reviews are paid for by the games industry
Quote
Posted on 19:21, December 01st 2007
 

put your comment here

CrazyCamel UPC
Metriweb TripTracker