The whole thing sounds a bit obvious though, you got a group of people who like to play games and probably a few of each console set up and food and drink.

Ofcourse the Wii is going to come out on top in a situation like that, how fun is it for anyone to just stand there and watch someone else play a game with a joypad, you got someone waving their arms about your going to find that more entertaining and want a go.

I remember the morning my mate got Samba de Amigo on the Dreamcast and we played it and thought it was ok but when i went round there the next night with another mate and he had a load of friends there we had an absolute blast with it.

I dont see how they can announce a winner when they didn't even include the x360. Both Wii user complained a bit about how it didnt always pick up on the motion sensing correctly. Maybe that something you just have to get a feeling for and hopefully not a big problem.

These tests or whatever you wana call them are allways stupid anyway.

You need to get all three consoles doing what they do best for a fair fight.
They should of had 8 X360's hooked up together running GOW mutlipayer.

Wii with a group of people playing Wii sports which seems to look like the most fun with friends.

PS3 with multiplayer Resistance as this seems to be from what ive read a great experience although the game doesnt look all that to me.

Then it would of been a fair comparison.

I don't think that would fairly pit the consoles up against each other fairly. You should get one game that appears on all three consoles (hoping that the developer isn't biased to a particular one) and let people play.

Show casing their "best game" doesn't really pit the consoles versus each other but the games.

If you ran the same game on all three console's then it would be a completely different story.

COD3 on PS3 against the X360 version, from what i've read the X360 version would win, all the reviews i've seen of COD3 on PS3 say it has slowdown and its been marked lower on PS3 by every review i've seen.

As it goes every game thats on both PS3 and X360 has scored lower on PS3.

Considering the graphical weakness of Wii, it would'nt be fair to run the same game on Wii thats running on either X360 or PS3 next to it.

Besides Wii plays totaly different and is aimed at different taste's.

wii and ps3 are relativaly new, and problems will show up.
also xbox 360 has some titles that are better then many titles, namely halo series and possibly GOW nintendo hasn't had games that compete with the 360 and wii, and the ps3 is really expensive.