Regarding the graphics, I agree that the engine already shows it age. However, the graphics still manage to shine due to terrific artwork and very impressive effects like normal mapping. The character models are also top notch. I think most game developers should learn from these guys.

i won't deny that, the darkness itself is pretty impressive and the surroundings are dark and gritty. but i find that there are already a couple of games that are having the same graphics or a little bit better :)

still for not using a completely new engine it's quite impressive what they did on a next-gen console.

I totally agree. I guess it just shows that even today talent and dedication pays off... :-)